Jessica Jones는 Marvel Comics의 캐릭터이지만 Avengers로 대표되고 내게 별로 매력적이지 않은 Marvel보다 내 흥미를 끄는 DC Comics 느낌을 주고, 그래서 그 TV series도 즐겁게 보았다. Jessica Jones가 DC 느낌이라는 의견을 가진 이들이 더 있지 않을까 싶어 Gemini에 물었더니 답이:

You’re not alone in that feeling! While Jessica Jones is undeniably a Marvel character, many people have noted that her tone and style often lean more towards what is traditionally associated with DC Comics.

Here’s why some people might feel that way:

• Darker and Grittier Tone: DC is often perceived as having a darker, more serious, and often more grounded approach to its characters and storytelling, especially in comparison to some of the more overtly fantastical and lighthearted elements often found in the broader Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) films. Jessica Jones, particularly the Netflix series, delves into very mature and psychological themes like trauma, abuse, and PTSD, which aligns with the grittier feel often found in DC properties like Batman or even some Vertigo imprints.
• Street-Level and Noir Elements: Jessica Jones operates as a private investigator in Hell’s Kitchen, dealing with street-level crime and personal demons rather than cosmic threats. This noir-detective style, coupled with her cynical and reluctant hero persona, is a common trope that has been heavily utilized in DC, particularly with characters like Batman, John Constantine, or even some aspects of the Gotham Central series.
• Focus on Psychological Depth: The show, and the comic Alias it’s based on, spends significant time exploring Jessica’s internal struggles and the psychological impact of her past, especially her relationship with Kilgrave. This deep dive into character psychology and moral ambiguity can feel more akin to the character-driven narratives often found in DC’s more mature titles.
• Less Overtly “Superheroic”: Jessica Jones actively tries to avoid being a superhero. She doesn’t wear a costume (anymore), she’s messy, she drinks, and she’s not interested in saving the world. This reluctance and anti-hero stance, while present in Marvel, is also a strong characteristic of many DC characters who operate in the shadows or outside traditional heroic archetypes.

Similar Opinions and References:

You can find discussions online, particularly on forums like Reddit and in reviews of the Jessica Jones series, where people express similar sentiments. Many reviewers and fans have pointed out the show’s departure from the typical “Marvel feel” and its embrace of a more mature, noir, and psychologically complex narrative, which resonates with elements found in DC’s storytelling.

It’s important to remember that both Marvel and DC have a wide range of tones and styles within their respective universes. While Marvel is often generalized as “lighter” and DC as “darker,” characters like Jessica Jones demonstrate that Marvel is perfectly capable of producing very gritty and mature content, just as DC has its share of lighter heroes. The perception often comes from the most popular or mainstream depictions of their characters.

References:

Discussions on Reddit (e.g., r/JessicaJones, r/Defenders) often feature comparisons of the show’s tone to other comic properties.

Reviews of the Jessica Jones Netflix series frequently highlight its darker and more mature themes.

Articles discussing the differences and similarities between Marvel and DC storytelling often touch upon characters like Jessica Jones as examples of Marvel’s darker side.